Skip to content
SoluWeld
  • Expert
  • Metallurgy
  • Calculations

Preheating steel: determining it under EN 1011-2

Carbon equivalent, diffusible hydrogen, heat input, combined thickness: how EN 1011-2 sets the preheat temperature of steel, and why an element missing from the mill certificate is not zero.

Julien Bachelet · Fondateur · IWE17 November 20265 min read

Where does the preheat on your WPS come from? Too often from an older procedure, or a round number "we have always used". Yet it is one of the parameters that decide the risk of cold cracking, a defect that can appear hours after welding, sometimes after inspection. EN 1011-2 gives a method to determine it. Here is its logic, without its charts.

Cold cracking needs three conditions at once

  1. Diffusible hydrogen in the weld metal and the HAZ (Heat-Affected Zone), brought mainly by moisture in consumables, flux or on the surface of the parts.
  2. A hard microstructure, typically martensitic, formed in the HAZ of a hardenable steel that cools quickly.
  3. Tensile stresses, residual or from restraint, all the higher as the assembly is thick and rigid.

Preheat acts on the first two: it slows cooling, which limits hard structures, and it gives hydrogen time to leave the joint while the metal is still hot. It does not make up for a poorly baked basic electrode.

Four parameters, and none can be ignored

Method A of EN 1011-2 combines four inputs to give a minimum preheat temperature:

  • The carbon equivalent CE (IIW) measures the hardenability of the steel: CE = C + Mn/6 + (Cr + Mo + V)/5 + (Ni + Cu)/15, in mass %. The higher it is, the more preheat is needed.
  • Diffusible hydrogen is graded in scales from A (more than 15 ml per 100 g of deposited metal) to E (3 ml or less). A consumable's grade only holds if its storage and baking are respected.
  • Heat input: the lower it is, the faster the cooling, the more preheat is needed. It accounts for the process thermal efficiency defined in EN 1011-1: at the same current, a fast run does not need the same preheat as a slow one.
  • Combined thickness is the sum of the thicknesses that conduct heat away from the joint. A branch on a thick header can need much more preheat than the branch thickness alone suggests.

Method B uses another carbon equivalent, CET = C + (Mn + Mo)/10 + (Cr + Cu)/20 + Ni/40, and covers steels that method A does not. The two do not necessarily give the same value: the steel grade determines the method, and the WPS must state which one was applied.

Preheat is set per joint, not per grade

Take the same non-alloy structural steel. A butt joint on thin plate, welded with a well-baked basic electrode at medium heat input, often needs no preheat. The same steel in a T-joint on heavy section, with a small fillet run fast and a higher-hydrogen consumable, needs considerably more. The carbon equivalent has not moved: combined thickness went up, heat input went down, hydrogen went up, and the three effects add up.

That is why a value copied from another WPS is rarely right. Working out heat input and joint geometry belongs to the same approach as the weld volume calculation: start from the actual joint, not from habit.

An element missing from the certificate is not zero

This is the most common trap, and the most dangerous. A mill certificate does not always report copper, nickel, molybdenum or vanadium, because the product standard does not require them. Counting them as zero lowers the carbon equivalent, and therefore the calculated preheat. The error always goes in the direction that cracks.

Three positions are defensible: obtain the full analysis, use the maximum content allowed by the product standard when it sets one (and write it down), or draw no conclusion while the data is missing.

Boron shows the risk. It appears in neither CE (IIW) nor CET, but it weighs 5 times its content in the Pcm of ISO/TR 17844, the highest coefficient in the formula. A few thousandths of a percent, an ordinary content in a boron steel, can shift the steel into another susceptibility class. A calculation where boron was never entered looks complete when it is not.

What goes with preheat

  • Interpass temperature. Preheat is a minimum to hold throughout welding. A maximum interpass temperature is often set too, to protect toughness. Both appear on the WPS.
  • Post-heating. On thick or highly restrained joints, holding or raising the temperature after the last run helps hydrogen escape. It is not post-weld heat treatment.
  • Measurement. It follows ISO 13916, at a distance from the groove set according to thickness. A reading taken close to the flame or the induction coil overstates the temperature of the part.

What SoluWeld does for you

The welding calculations module determines the preheat temperature under EN 1011-2 from the chemical composition, diffusible hydrogen, heat input and combined thickness. It also calculates carbon equivalents and the t8/5 cooling time. An element missing from the certificate is never counted as zero: the calculation asks you for it. The result carries over to the WPS, managed in the qualifications and procedures module.

Evaluate the platform on your real projects.

Thirty minutes on video to measure the time saved on records and the autonomy SoluWeld brings to your teams.