Skip to content
SoluWeld
  • Intermediate
  • Quality

The quality levels of ISO 5817

Level B, C or D: what ISO 5817 sets, where the required level comes from and how it translates into acceptance criteria for non-destructive testing.

Julien Bachelet · Fondateur · IWE14 November 20264 min read

"Welds to level B." The line appears in many specifications, often with nothing more. Yet it commits the fabricator on every imperfection of every bead, and it changes the price of the job. You still need to know what ISO 5817 sets, and what it leaves to other documents.

Three levels for the same imperfections

For arc-welded joints in steel, nickel, titanium and their alloys, ISO 5817 gives acceptance limits for the imperfections listed in ISO 6520-1. It defines three levels:

LevelRequirementTypical use
BStringentPressure equipment, highly stressed structures, WPQR
CIntermediateOrdinary steelwork and plate work
DModerateLightly loaded structures, limited consequences of failure

For each imperfection, the standard states whether it is permitted at each level and up to what size. The typical uses are given for information and are not a general rule.

The level is not chosen, it is read

The contract, the construction code or the product standard state which acceptance level applies. The level can also vary from one joint to another on the same part. A drawing that gives it joint by joint avoids paying for level B where C is enough.

The level sets neither the method nor the extent of testing

The acceptance level says neither how many welds to examine nor how to examine them.

  • The method is chosen according to the material, thickness, joint type and the defects sought. The article on non-destructive testing covers that choice.
  • The extent of testing (100 %, 10 %, one joint in twenty) comes from the construction code or the contract. It generally depends on how critical the structure or equipment is and on the joint type.
  • The acceptance level of each method follows from the quality level. ISO 17635 gives this correspondence, method by method. In radiography, for example, level B corresponds to acceptance level 1 of ISO 10675-1, C to level 2, D to level 3.

This chain has a practical consequence: an inspection report that cites the quality level but not the acceptance level of its method does not let anyone check that the right criterion was applied.

The limits of non-destructive testing

ISO 5817 judges geometric imperfections. It says nothing about the metallurgical structure, hardness or toughness of the joint: those properties belong to the qualified procedure and the tests of the WPQR. A weld without a single visible imperfection can therefore be unacceptable, for instance if it was made outside the range of the WPQR. That is why non-destructive testing after welding should not systematically replace inspection during production.

What SoluWeld does for you

SoluWeld carries the quality level on each weld and derives from it the acceptance criteria of each inspection method. NDT reports are linked to the identified welds, with their result. See the welding coordination module, or request a demo.

Evaluate the platform on your real projects.

Thirty minutes on video to measure the time saved on records and the autonomy SoluWeld brings to your teams.