A weld goes to repair. It is ground, rewelded, reinspected: half a day lost, sometimes more. This hidden cost usually does not show up in the cost of non-quality. Worse, the defect had a simple cause, and it will happen again on the next weld if nobody names it. This article goes through the most common defects, what causes them and what corrects them.
An imperfection is not necessarily a defect
Every weld carries imperfections: some excess weld metal, a few gas pores, a slight undercut. ISO 6520-1 classifies them in six families, identified by the first digit of their reference number: cracks (1), cavities (2), solid inclusions (3), lack of fusion and penetration (4), imperfect shape (5) and miscellaneous (6).
An imperfection becomes a defect when it exceeds the permitted limit. That limit depends on the required quality level, which is the subject of ISO 5817 and its levels B, C and D. The same indication can be accepted on ordinary steelwork and rejected on pressure equipment.
Cracks
A crack is a sharp notch that can propagate in service. It is rejected in almost every case. Three origins come up again and again:
- Cold cracking, caused by hydrogen, in a hardenable steel that cooled too fast. It can appear several hours after welding. The remedy: preheat determined under EN 1011-2, low-hydrogen consumables properly baked, sufficient heat input.
- Hot cracking, during solidification, often at the centre of a narrow, deep bead. It is promoted by impurities in the metal (sulphur, phosphorus) and by a run that penetrates too deep for its width.
- Crater cracks, at the end of a bead, when the arc is cut abruptly. Filling the crater before stopping is usually enough.
The two underlying mechanisms are covered in the article on cold and hot cracking.
Porosity is almost always a shielding or cleanliness problem
Spherical gas pores, isolated or clustered, mean gas trapped in the weld pool. The causes, in order of frequency on the shop floor:
- a draught that blows away the shielding gas, an open door, a fan;
- a badly set gas flow, too low but also too high, which draws in air;
- a nozzle clogged with spatter;
- greasy, wet, rusty, painted or galvanised surfaces;
- covered electrodes or flux that have picked up moisture.
Wormholes, elongated pores, usually point to heavier contamination or to gas rising from a joint that cannot vent, such as a T-joint on coated sheet.
Inclusions and lack of fusion often come from an abrupt or hurried movement
Slag inclusions appear with covered electrodes, flux-cored wire or submerged arc when the slag of one run was not fully removed before the next. A bead that is too convex creates corners where slag stays trapped. The remedy is grinding and brushing between runs, and flatter beads. In TIG, the equivalent is the tungsten inclusion, when the electrode touches the pool.
Lack of fusion is the most dangerous of the family. The deposited metal lies against the side wall or the previous run without bonding to it. It happens when heat input is too low for the thickness, travel speed too high, the torch badly angled, or when the pool runs ahead of the arc. In short-arc MAG on thick material, it is a classic risk. It is a planar defect, invisible at the surface, which radiography detects poorly unless it lies along the beam axis.
Lack of penetration leaves the root unfused. Root face too thick, gap too small, current too low: the joint preparation and fit-up are often at fault before the welder.
Imperfect shape: visible, therefore avoidable
- Undercut, a groove along the toe of the bead: current or voltage too high, travel speed too fast, wrong torch angle.
- Excess weld metal: it adds no strength and creates a notch at the toe, harmful in fatigue.
- Overlap, metal lying over the plate without bonding to it: travel too slow, pool too fluid.
- Linear misalignment between the two parts: it is fixed at fit-up, not during welding.
- Spatter and stray arc strikes outside the joint: the latter create a hardened, sometimes cracked, spot on the plate.
How to avoid repeated repairs?
Repairing a weld without looking for the cause means paying for the same repair next week. Three reflexes:
- record the defect with its weld number, its welder and its procedure: a series of pores at the same station points to the station, not the welder;
- compare the actual parameters with the WPS (Welding Procedure Specification): repeated lack of fusion often means the actual heat input is outside what was qualified;
- choose the right detection method: lack of fusion cannot be seen at the surface, and each non-destructive testing method has its blind spots.
What SoluWeld does for you
In the welding coordination module, every inspection and every nonconformity is linked to the identified weld, the welder and the WPS applied. The welder and the procedure involved are therefore known as soon as the defect is recorded, and the repair stays traced with its inspection. You can request a demo.