Your welder is qualified in process 135? Good, but qualified for what exactly? A welder qualification does not say "this welder can weld". It says that he passed a given test piece, and that this result covers a precise set of production situations: the range of qualification. Before assigning a welder to a joint, the welding coordinator checks that every characteristic of the joint falls inside it.
A welder qualification is a particular combination of several essential variables
An essential variable is a parameter whose change alters the difficulty of the welder's task. Two rules are enough to read the whole standard:
- Each variable is read on its own. The range is the intersection of the ranges of every variable. A joint covered for position but not for diameter is not covered.
- The harder covers the easier, never the reverse. A test made under a more demanding condition covers the conditions considered simpler.
What bounds the range
| Variable | What the test covers | What it does not cover |
|---|---|---|
| Process (ISO 4063) | The process welded | Other processes, except the equivalences provided |
| Product | Pipe: pipe and plate | Plate: pipe below a threshold diameter |
| Weld type | Butt weld: fillet only with a supplementary fillet test | Fillet: never butt welds |
| Filler material group (FM1 to FM6) | The group welded and the groups listed by the standard | Other groups |
| Filler material type | The type welded and those it covers (covering, solid wire, cored wire) | Other types |
| Thickness, diameter | A range around the value welded | Values outside the range |
| Position (ISO 6947) | The position welded and positions considered easier | Harder positions |
| Backing | No backing: with and without | With backing: welding without backing |
| Layers | Multi-layer: multi and single layer | Single layer: multi-layer |
Two details that often change the answer:
- In multi-process welding (root in 141, fill in 111 for instance), a single test piece qualifies both processes, each for the thickness it deposited itself, not for the total thickness.
- For butt welds, the thickness that counts is the deposited thickness, process by process. Above a threshold the range becomes open-ended: a test piece of 12 mm or more covers any thickness from 5 mm. For other cases, read the table of the standard, not your memory.
The traps that keep coming up in audits
Vertical up and vertical down are two different skills
Vertical up (PF) and vertical down (PG) do not cover each other. A welder qualified vertical up who welds vertical down is out of range, even if "it is vertical either way".
Small diameters are qualified separately
A qualification obtained on plate, or on a large-diameter pipe, does not cover small pipes. In a piping shop, the diameter is checked joint by joint, not line by line.
Fillet welds do not come with butt welds
"He is qualified for butt welds, so he can do fillets." The reasoning sounds right, and the standard does not follow it without a supplementary fillet test. If your production is mostly fillet welds, qualify the welder on fillet welds.
How do you check that a production weld matches the welder qualification?
- Start from the joint: process, product, weld type, filler material, thickness, diameter, position, backing.
- Compare each variable with the range of the qualification of the intended welder.
- Never treat unknown data as compliant: go and find it.
- Check that the qualification is valid on the welding date.
Bonus: check that the WPS applied is covered by a WPQR.
This check requires every weld to be identified and linked to its welder: that is the purpose of weld mapping.
How SoluWeld helps
SoluWeld calculates the range of each welder qualification variable by variable, citing the clause of the standard it is based on. Joint coverage is checked on both the welder qualification side and the WPQR side. Details are on the qualifications and procedures page, and the link with weld tracking on the welding coordination page. You can also book a demo.