Pricing a welded joint often comes down to multiplying a length by a price per metre drawn from experience. That works as long as jobs look alike. It becomes fragile as soon as the thickness, the process or the position changes. The welding cost calculation presented here starts from the joint geometry and rebuilds the cost item by item. You then know what really weighs, and what to act on.
The formulas below are the ones used by our welding cost calculator. It starts from the deposited mass, which you can get with the weld volume calculator.
The five cost items
The cost of a joint breaks down into direct items:
- filler metal: wire, electrodes or rods;
- shielding gas for gas-shielded processes;
- flux for submerged arc welding;
- electrical energy drawn by the power source;
- labour: the welder's time, over the whole time spent at the station.
Edge preparation, grinding and fume extraction are covered by the operating factor; inspection, repairs and equipment depreciation can be built into the hourly rate. They count in a full cost price, and can be added separately.
Labour is by far the largest part of the cost of a weld
In most shops, time costs far more than consumables. On average, it accounts for more than 80% of the price of a weld.
Comparing processes
Without a universal figure, the processes can be placed relative to one another:
- 111, covered electrode: low deposition efficiency, modest deposition rate, frequent stops to change electrodes and chip slag. High cost per kilo deposited, but simple, versatile equipment on site.
- 141, TIG: deposition efficiency close to 100%, but a low deposition rate. Reserved for root passes, thin sections and demanding quality requirements.
- 135 and 136, MAG solid or flux-cored wire: a clearly higher deposition rate and a better operating factor. Gas-shielded flux-cored wire often makes positional welding easier.
- 138, metal-cored wire: good efficiency and a high deposition rate, without heavy slag.
- 121, submerged arc: very high deposition rate and high operating factor when mechanised, but limited to the flat and horizontal positions and to parts that justify the set-up. The flux adds to the cost.
Levers for saving money
Reduce the mass to deposit
- Reduce the groove angle where access allows.
- Hold the root gap at tack-up.
- Switch to X or K grooves on heavy sections.
- Keep reinforcement to what is actually needed.
- Weld the required throat, without oversizing fillet welds.
Choose the right process
The process sets the deposition rate. On a long, thick joint, moving from covered electrode to MAG or flux-cored wire, or from MAG to submerged arc when the part allows, changes the arc time by an order of magnitude.
Weld in the flat position
The flat and horizontal positions allow higher deposition rates than vertical or overhead. A positioner or turning rolls can bring a joint into a favourable position.
Improve the operating factor
Prepare parts before they reach the station, keep wire and gas close at hand, limit handling, and group welds that use the same welding procedure.
Limit repairs
A repair after inspection means gouging, grinding, welding and inspecting again. A suitable welding procedure, welders qualified for the right range and well-controlled settings cost less than the repair.
On the other hand, and this is counter-intuitive
A cheaper wire saves little money, and can even cost you more. Some low-cost wires can have lower deposition efficiencies than premium wires. Their lower quality can also lead to touch-ups or weld repairs, which directly affect the final cost of the weld. To choose the right filler metal for your application, SoluWeld has a tool that suggests suitable filler metals by comparing the catalogues of 10 filler metal manufacturers.
How SoluWeld helps
SoluWeld runs this calculation in its welding calculation modules, each one linked to a project and a weld. The assumptions used, process, efficiency and operating factor, stay visible with the result. The same software manages the welding procedures and welder qualifications linked to those welds. A demo shows how it all fits together.
The tool also lets you simulate different scenarios ahead of an equipment investment (process automation, moving to a process with a higher deposition rate, and so on) or a change in your processes (narrow-gap grooves, hiring a preparer, and so on).