Skip to content
SoluWeld
  • Intermediate
  • Quality

ISO 3834: choosing the right level of welding quality requirements

ISO 3834-2, -3 or -4: how to pick the right level of quality requirements for fusion welding, and what an auditor actually checks on the shop floor.

Julien Bachelet · Fondateur · IWE8 November 20265 min read

You weld under ISO 9001? That's good, but it isn't enough. Welding is a so-called "special process" because you cannot fully verify a joint after the fact without destroying it. Quality therefore has to be controlled during fabrication, and that is exactly what the ISO 3834 series is about. It describes what a manufacturer must have under control for its welds to conform, every time.

  • ISO 3834 is not a quality management system. It works alongside ISO 9001 without replacing it, and can apply without it.
  • It applies to the manufacturer, in the shop as on site, for fusion welding of metallic materials.
  • It is not tied to a product. The construction code or the contract makes it mandatory and sets the level.

What the ISO 3834 series is for

The series has several parts. Part 1 gives the criteria for choosing the level. Parts 2, 3 and 4 define three levels of quality requirements. Part 5 lists the documents you must comply with to claim conformity to the previous parts. A part 6 (technical report) gives implementation guidelines.

For a small fabrication, piping or structural steel shop, the first question is often the worst posed: which level applies to me?

The three levels: comprehensive, standard, elementary

LevelPartTypical profileWhat changes
ComprehensiveISO 3834-2Pressure equipment, highly loaded structures, serious consequences of failureAll requirements apply, documented and verifiable
StandardISO 3834-3Ordinary structural steel, industrial piping, moderately loaded welded structuresRequirements close to the comprehensive level, with some elements lightened or left to the contract
ElementaryISO 3834-4Simple structures, low loads, limited consequences of failureMinimal requirements, little imposed formality

How to choose your level

The level is not chosen by gut feeling. It follows, in this order:

1. From the customer and the contract

If the specification imposes a level, the matter is settled. Also read the attached technical specifications: a level can be imposed indirectly, through a reference to a product standard.

2. From the construction code or product standard

This is the most common case.

  • Structural steel (EN 1090-2): the execution class sets the level. In practice, EXC1 points to the elementary level, EXC2 to the standard level, EXC3 and EXC4 to the comprehensive level. CE marking of structural components relies on this correspondence.
  • Pressure equipment (Directive 2014/68/EU, the PED): the directive does not cite ISO 3834 as such, but the harmonised construction standards (for vessels or industrial piping, for example) refer to it. The comprehensive level is common there.
  • Rail, nuclear, offshore: sector-specific frameworks generally set the level.

3. Failing that, from a risk analysis

If nothing imposes a level, ISO 3834-1 offers criteria: product loading (static or fatigue), consequences of failure, manufacturing complexity, materials and thicknesses, processes used.

What an auditor actually looks at

To check how you manage welding quality, the auditor picks a part or an order at random and traces it back.

Auditor's questionEvidence expected
"Who made this weld?"Joint identification, welder identity, date
"Was this welder qualified for it?"Valid welder qualification whose range covers process, position, thickness, diameter, joint type
"With which procedure?"WPS at the workstation, supported by a WPQR or another accepted route
"Consumables?"Certificates, storage and baking conditions
"Who coordinates?"Written appointment, defined tasks and responsibilities
"Were the planned inspections carried out?"Inspection plan, reports, acceptance criteria
"Measuring equipment?"Calibration or verification records

The auditor also checks that the six-monthly confirmations of welder qualifications are done and signed. It is one of the most common findings.

Through these questions, you cover all the mandatory points of ISO 3834.

Common mistakes

  • Common mistakes. A WPS out of range, a welder qualification not confirmed or no longer valid, inspections not carried out, traceability "patched together"...

To go further on the link between welding procedures and welders, see our page on managing qualifications and procedures.

How SoluWeld helps

SoluWeld links every weld to its WPS, to the WPQR that supports it and to the qualified welder who made it. Ranges of qualification are calculated variable by variable, with the clause of the standard cited. Inspection tracking, the welding book and the manufacturing record feed directly into the evidence an ISO 3834 auditor expects. Discover the welding coordination module or book a demo.

Evaluate the platform on your real projects.

Thirty minutes on video to measure the time saved on records and the autonomy SoluWeld brings to your teams.