WPS, WPQR, welder qualification: three documents, three questions
| Document | Question it answers | Reference standard (steels) |
|---|---|---|
| WPS (welding procedure specification) | How do we weld this joint? | ISO 15609-1 for arc welding |
| WPQR (welding procedure qualification record) | Does this procedure produce a sound joint? | ISO 15614-1 (test route) |
| Welder qualification | Can this welder carry it out? | ISO 9606-1 |
The WPQR: evidence
The WPQR (Welding Procedure Qualification Record) is a record. It captures what was actually welded during a test and the results of the examinations and tests that followed: visual inspection, non-destructive testing, tensile, bend and impact tests, macro examination, hardness, as the standard and the code require. It is signed by the examiner or examining body. A WPQR is never amended: it bears witness to a test that took place.
The WPS: a work instruction
The WPS (Welding Procedure Specification) is the document the welder must have in front of them. It sets the process, base material, joint type and preparation, positions, filler metals and gases, electrical parameters, preheat, interpass temperature, run sequence and any heat treatment. It is written by the manufacturer, under the responsibility of its welding coordination. A WPS is derived from a WPQR.
The welder qualification: an individual skill
The welder qualification certifies that a named person passed a test under given conditions. It concerns the welder, not the procedure. It is kept alive by periodic confirmation, and its prolongation follows the methods set out in the current edition of the standard.
The order of qualification
The classic chain, through the qualification test route, has five steps.
- The pWPS. The coordinator writes a preliminary specification from the need: material, thicknesses, positions, impact or hardness requirements of the code. It is a working hypothesis.
- The qualification test. A welder makes a test piece to the pWPS, in front of the examiner. The parameters actually used are recorded.
- The WPQR. Examinations and tests are carried out. If they conform, the record is issued, with its range of qualification.
- The production WPS. The manufacturer writes one or more WPSs whose parameters stay within the range covered by the WPQR. One WPQR can support several WPSs.
- Qualified welders. Every welder who will use the WPS must hold a welder qualification whose range covers the production conditions. The welder who passed the WPQR test can, in general and under conditions, be qualified by that test.
Routes for qualifying a welding procedure (WPQR)
| Route | Standard | Principle | Watch point |
|---|---|---|---|
| Qualification test | ISO 15614 (part 1 for arc welding of steels) | Weld and test a standard test piece | The most general route, often the only one accepted for demanding applications |
| Pre-production test | ISO 15613 | Weld a part representative of production | Range limited to the conditions of the part tested |
| Standard welding procedure | ISO 15612 | Use a procedure already qualified and published as a standard | Restrictions of use depending on materials and codes |
| Previous experience | ISO 15611 | Show with documented evidence that the procedure has performed satisfactorily | The evidence must be solid and traceable |
| Tested consumables | ISO 15610 | Rely on the tests of the filler metals | Restricted applicability, generally to simple cases |
The range of qualification: the heart of the matter
A WPQR qualifies a range on grounds of mechanical and metallurgical performance
A WPQR does not only qualify what was welded: it qualifies a range around the test. This is the range of qualification. It is built variable by variable. Essential variables are those whose change beyond the set limits requires a new qualification. They include:
- the base material group, under the ISO/TR 15608 grouping system;
- the thickness range and, for pipes, the diameter range;
- the welding process;
- the joint and run type (butt, fillet, single or multi-run);
- the filler metal and its classification;
- the type of current;
- preheat, interpass temperature and post-weld heat treatment;
- heat input, when impact or hardness requirements apply.
The welder qualification proves a welder's ability to use a process under particular conditions
The welder qualification has its own logic. For a welder qualified to ISO 9606-1, the base material is not a variable in the same way: you reason mainly in terms of process, product type (plate or pipe), joint type, filler metal group, coating or wire type, thickness, diameter and position.
Confusing the two ranges is a common mistake: a welder can be qualified for a thickness the WPS does not cover, and vice versa.
Why link every weld to the production chain
- the weld is identified on the drawing or the parts list;
- it is made to an identified WPS;
- the joint's parameters (material, thickness, diameter, position, joint type) are within the range of the WPQR supporting that WPS;
- the welder who made it holds a welder qualification valid on the welding date, whose range covers the joint;
- the planned inspections were carried out and conform.
If a single link is missing, the weld is not justified. That is exactly what an ISO 3834 auditor, a notified body or a customer checks by picking a weld at random.
The most common mistakes
- A WPS written "by hand" with a parameter outside the WPQR range.
- A production thickness or diameter outside the range, discovered after welding.
- A welder qualification used beyond its expiry date.
- A welder qualified in the flat position welding in the horizontal position.
- A WPQR cited on a WPS outside its range of qualification.
How SoluWeld helps
SoluWeld manages welder qualifications, WPQRs and WPSs in a single repository, to ISO 9606-1, ISO 15614-1 and ASME IX. Ranges of qualification are calculated variable by variable, with the clause of the standard cited. Every weld is linked to its WPS, to the WPQR that supports it and to the welder who made it. See the qualifications and procedures page, the welding coordination module, or book a demo.